If you’ve just hired an associate, or you’re about to, one of the first things you have to settle is what their paycheck is based on. It’s tempting to copy another practice’s offer, but your plan has to fit your own collections and overhead.
The pay plan reaches your overhead, your payroll, your own paycheck and, a few years from now, what a buy-in looks like. We’ve already written about when to hire an associate dentist, so this post picks up after the hire.
How Are Most Dental Associates Paid?
Many dental associates are paid a percentage of the dentistry they do, measured either as production or as collections, sometimes with a daily guarantee underneath it. Some practices pay a straight salary instead, and the ADA notes that Medicaid-heavy practices often pay a salary and add bonuses tied to other measures.
The ADA’s career guide on how associate pay can vary lays out three common bases. Total production is what your fee schedule says the work is worth, and billable production is what you can actually charge once insurance contracts set the fee. Collections is the money that really lands in your account.
The ADA’s guide doesn’t publish a going rate. In the market generally, the percentage commonly runs somewhere around 25% to 35%, depending on your market and the associate’s experience. Which of those three numbers it’s applied to matters just as much, though. The same 30% offer on total production and on collections can turn into very different paychecks.
Production vs. Collections Decides Who Carries the Risk
Paying on production puts the collection risk on you, and paying on collections shares it with the associate. Insurance adjustments lower what you can bill, and a patient balance that never gets paid lowers what you collect after that, so somebody has to absorb each of those gaps.
Say your associate produces $2,500 a day and you pay 30%. On production, that’s $750 a day.
Now say your practice collects 95% of what it bills. If all of that work is billable and collects at the same rate, they’d earn about $712 a day on collections instead. The gap looks small, but over a full year of working days it adds up to several thousand dollars, and the pay plan decides whether you absorb all of it or split it.
Owners like collections-based pay because you only pay on money you’ve received, and associates push back because they don’t run your front desk or insurance follow-up. The ADA’s guide notes that when a practice’s collection percentage is above 98%, there’s minimal difference between paying on production and paying on collections. So it helps to know whether your rate is measured against billable or total production.
So before you argue about the percentage, look at your own collection rate. If yours is low, it’s worth finding out why before you decide how much of that risk the associate should share, because a low rate is also when a guarantee starts to come up.
Daily Guarantees and Draws Protect the Ramp-Up
A daily guarantee is a minimum the associate earns for each day worked, and it exists because new associates rarely fill a schedule right away. The ADA’s guide describes a collection percentage under 94% as low for a practice that pays on billable production. To stay competitive, it says, that practice may offer a daily guarantee, pay based on production or a straight salary.
A guarantee usually works as a floor, so the agreement should say whether the associate earns the greater of the daily minimum or their percentage, and how often the two get reconciled. A draw works a little differently, because it’s an advance against future percentage pay. If the agreement makes the draw recoverable, a shortfall in a slow pay period gets made up out of later, busier ones.
That makes a guarantee a cost you’ve agreed to carry while the associate builds a patient base, while a draw behaves more like a loan. If the associate leaves before catching up, collecting that balance gets awkward. Whichever one you use, put an end date on it in writing so the guarantee doesn’t quietly turn into the salary.
The ramp-up months are also when a new hire can squeeze your cash flow, which is why we like to model associate pay month by month before the offer goes out.
Should Your Associate Be W-2 or 1099?
Whether an associate is a W-2 employee or a 1099 contractor depends on how the relationship actually works, not on what the agreement calls it. The IRS’s guidance on independent contractor or employee status groups the evidence into three categories: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship.
Put simply, the IRS wants to know whether you control what the worker does and how they do it, whether you control the business side of the job, and whether the relationship is ongoing and central to your business. An associate who works the hours you set, in your operatories, with your staff and supplies, looks a lot like an employee under that test, even with a signed contractor agreement.
The tax difference between the two is real. For an employee, the IRS says you withhold income, Social Security and Medicare taxes, pay the matching employer portion of Social Security and Medicare, and pay unemployment tax. For an independent contractor, you generally don’t withhold or pay those taxes, which is exactly why the 1099 label can be tempting. It’s also why treating someone as a contractor without a reasonable basis can leave the practice liable for the employment taxes it skipped.
If you’re truly unsure, the IRS lets either the business or the worker file Form SS-8 for a determination. Most owners are better off setting up the relationship correctly from the start and, if the associate is an employee, running them through the same dental payroll as the rest of the team.
Associate Pay Changes What’s Left for Your Own Compensation
Every dollar you pay an associate changes the profit left for you, and if your practice is an S-corp, a new hire is a good moment to check whether your own salary still fits the work you’re doing.
Payroll on its own is compliance work. When we run a practice’s payroll alongside its tax planning, we can see right away whether an associate hire changes what the owner should be paying themselves.
If the associate is covering some of your clinical days, your own W-2 wage may need a fresh look. The IRS lists the duties you handle and the time you put into the business among the factors for reasonable compensation. Our post on reasonable compensation for dentists covers how that wage is set. It’s also worth checking your retirement plan, since an associate on your W-2 payroll may need to be included in it.
The offer letter won’t show you any of this, but your payroll, your plan contributions and your next tax return will.
Build a Pay Plan That Can Grow Into a Buy-In
The best associate pay plan still makes sense when the associate becomes a partner, because how you pay someone now sets expectations that are hard to unwind later.
Let’s look at an example. A practice is bringing in the next generation of the family. The son joins, and within about a year collections are climbing, partly from procedures the father never offered. Both of them can see a buy-in coming, and the question is whether the structure will be ready before the son’s momentum gets ahead of the paperwork.
In that situation, the entity conversation should happen before the contracts get written. The right setup can give both dentists more flexibility from a tax perspective, so neither one is locked into pay driven purely by what they produce. A straight percentage-of-production plan works fine for an associate, but it can work against you once that associate owns part of the practice and you’re both deciding what to take home.
That’s why we like associate agreements that already point toward ownership, with production expectations, a timeline and a valuation approach agreed early. One caution is that this path belongs in the agreement when ownership is really on the table. It shouldn’t be a sweetener to keep an associate from leaving. If retention is the worry, there are better ways to pay someone more than a piece of the practice. If you’re on the other side of that table, our guide on whether to buy into your dental practice walks through it from the associate’s point of view.
What Should You Review in Your Associate Agreement Every Year?
Every associate agreement deserves an annual look at the pay base, the percentage, any guarantee, the classification and how it all fits your own pay. A plan that was fair in year one can drift either way by year three.
These are the questions we’d ask each year:
- Has your collection rate changed enough to make a production or collections base unfair to one side?
- Is the guarantee still in effect, and should it be?
- Do the facts of the relationship still match how the associate is classified?
- Did the associate’s production change your own W-2 wage or your retirement plan contributions?
- If a buy-in is on the horizon, does the pay plan still lead there?
It’s a good review to fold into year-end planning with our dental CFO services team, because the associate’s agreement, your payroll and your tax return all have to tell the same story.
If you liked this one, you’ll probably also like our guide on when to hire an associate dentist and the financial signs your practice is ready.
If you’re writing an associate offer or rethinking one, Core Advisors can model the pay plan alongside your payroll, your own compensation and your retirement plan, so they all work together. Start the conversation.
This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, investment or financial advice. Pay ranges are typical market observations and vary by practice, specialty and market. Consult your own tax, legal or financial advisor before acting on anything here.
Until next time!